STIHL SH 86 C-E vs. STIHL SH 56 C-E: Which Shredder Vac is Right for You?

When it comes to choosing the right shredder vac for your yard maintenance needs, STIHL offers two impressive models: the SH 86 C-E and the SH 56 C-E. Both machines are designed to make quick work of leaves, debris, and other organic matter, but which one is the best fit for your clearing needs?

STIHL is a leading brand of leaf blowers, and for good reason. Their high-power gas models are exactly what large yards and gardens need to cover all bases.

The brand’s SH 86 C-E and its SH 56 C-E sibling are both standout gas-powered “shredder vac” leaf blowers. Though they share a lot of the same key features, they’re also different enough to serve unique purposes.

Want to know exactly what makes these blowers tick? In this article, we’ll break both shredder vacs down to show you what sets them apart. We’ll then compare their features, usability, general performance, and more. This lets you figure out which one is worth the investment.

What Are Shredder Vacs?

Leaf blower shredder vacs, also known as shredder vacuums or vacuum shredders are versatile outdoor power tools combining the functionality of a leaf blower and shredder into a single, efficient unit.

You can easily collect leaves, small twigs, and other yard debris by using the blower function, while the shredder vac function allows you to reduce the volume of the collected material through the built-in vacuum and shredding mechanism.

The shredding function of these tools is particularly beneficial, as it can reduce the collected debris to a fraction of its original size. This not only saves space in the tool’s collection bag but also creates a nutrient-rich mulch that you can use in your garden or compost pile.

Model Name Unraveled

STIHL uses naming conventions across their product lines, with letters often representing specific features or technologies. Understanding these letters can help you quickly identify the key characteristics of a particular model. So let’s take a look at the letters “SH”, “C”, and “E” in the STIHL shredder vac model names.

  • The letter combination “SH” simply refers to the category “Shredder Vacuum” while the letters “C” and “E” refer to specific features incorporated into the shredder vac models.

  • The letter “C” stands for “Comfort”. This indicates that the tools are designed with user comfort in mind. While STIHL’s comfort features, such as ergonomic design, soft-grip handles and anti-vibration technology, may vary between “C” models, the overall goal is to reduce fatigue and improve the user experience during extended periods of use.

  • The letter “E” refers to STIHL’s Easy2Start™ system – a technology developed by STIHL and another one of STIHL’s comfort features – to make starting your tool a more user-friendly and accessible experience, regardless of your strength or experience level.

A Quick Comparison

Before we get into a detailed review of both leaf vacuum shredders, you should know the basics of each and how they stack up. A leaf blower’s specs can paint quite the picture of its performance. These numbers don’t necessarily tell the full story, but might get you a first idea about which one seems the better performer. Here’s a simple rundown of both models:

ModelDisplacementWeightAir VelocityAir VolumeFuel Capacity
SH 86 C-E27.2cc12.2 lbs170 MPH444 CFM14.9 oz
SH 56 C-E27.2cc11.5 lbs159 MPH412 CFM18.3 oz

Like we said, this isn’t enough to make your final decision. That can only come after reading about the shredder vacs in more detail.

A Closer Look

While both shredder vacs have a lot in common, learning exactly what sets them apart helps you make the right buying decision. So, what makes the SH 86 C-E and SH 56 C-E different to one another? Let’s get into it.

SH 86 C-E Tech Specs

  • Displacement: 27.2cc
  • Weight: 12.2 lbs (dry – vacuum mode) – 9.9 lbs (dry – blower mode)
  • Idle speed: 2,500 RPM
  • Blowing force: 15 Newtons
  • Max air velocity: 170 MPH
  • Air volume at nozzle: 444 CFM
  • Engine power: 1.1 brake horsepower
  • Fuel capacity: 14.9 oz
  • Vibration force: 2.5 m/s² (left), 1.9 m/s² (right)
  • Noise rating: 70 db(A)
  • Bag Capacity: 1.5 cu. ft.

SH 56 C-E Tech Specs

  • Displacement: 27.2cc
  • Weight: 11.5 lbs (dry – vacuum mode) – 9.3 lbs (dry – blower mode)
  • Idle speed: 2,500 RPM
  • Blowing force: 13 Newtons
  • Max air velocity: 159 MPH
  • Air volume at nozzle: 412 CFM
  • Engine power: 0.9 brake horsepower
  • Fuel capacity: 18.3 oz
  • Vibration force: 9.1 m/s² (left), 8.0 m/s² (right)
  • Noise rating: 70 db(A)
  • Bag Capacity: 1.5 cu. ft.

Intended Use

STIHL classifies the SH 56 C-E as a shredder vac for residential use, ideal for homeowners tackling yard work and light landscaping tasks. On the other hand, the SH 86 C-E is considered a professional-grade shredder vac, better suited for more demanding and extensive landscaping projects. This explains the latter’s extra power (and price).

Both have a 27.2cc engine, but the SH 86 C-E has more raw engine power (1.1 bhp vs. 0.9 bhp). Yeah, sure, this doesn’t seem like a lot, but even this slight increase affects which tasks each unit excels at.

Both can handle light tasks such as basic leaf clearing and vacuuming. However, the SH 86 C-E has just that little bit extra power for dealing with stubborn piles, especially with wet leaves and debris. That’s why it’s a professional leaf blower, after all; it simply has the juice for larger-scale projects.

The units’ blowing force, air volume, and maximum air velocity all back this up. The SH 86 C-E offers a small but significant improvement over the SH 56 C-E in each. If you’re concerned about power, go for the SH 86 C-E.

Power Source

Both shredder vacs are gas-powered tools, meaning any emissions, exhaust, or noise concerns you have about one also applies to the other. They’ve both got a 70 db(A) noise rating, which is around the same as (fittingly) a household vacuum cleaner.

However, the 56 C-E has a higher fuel capacity — 18.3 oz compared to the 86 C-E’s 14.9 oz. If that’s a major issue and you’d rather refuel the blower vac less often, even if it means less power, opt for the 56 C-E.

As two-stroke units, these shredder vacs run on a 50:1 gas/oil mixture; always stick to that ratio, anything else will just damage either tool. They both refuel the same way, and it’s best to get yourself a filler nozzle to make refueling simpler.

Anti-Vibration Technology

Anti-vibration features are crucial when choosing a power tool for extended use, as they significantly improve user comfort and reduce fatigue. Prolonged exposure to engine vibrations can lead to discomfort, numbness, and even long-term health issues such as hand-arm vibration syndrome (HAVS).

The SH 86 C-E has a built-in four-spring anti-vibration system, which the 56 C-E completely lacks. Just look at the numbers to see the difference. The SH 56 C-E actually has around quadruple the vibrational force.

This makes the SH 86 C-E more comfortable to use over longer periods. This is particularly important for professionals or homeowners with larger properties who may spend several hours using the tool continuously. This feature alone could be the deciding factor when choosing between the two models.

STIHL Easy2Start™

The STIHL SH 86 C-E and SH 56 C-E feature different stop/start systems – a stop/start lever and a stop/start switch, respectively. The choice largely comes down to personal preference. Some users may find the separate lever system more intuitive and easier to use, while others may prefer the simplicity of a combination switch.

More importantly, both tools use STIHL’s Easy2Start™ system. You won’t have to worry about not bringing enough force to the table. A specially designed starter handle and spring mechanism reduce the pulling force required to start the engine.

That makes it particularly beneficial for those who may have difficulty with traditional pull-start systems or those who use their equipment frequently and want to minimize the strain associated with repeated starting.

General Ease of Use

The SH 86 C-E’s extra power unfortunately has a tradeoff. It’s slightly bulkier and has a weight of 12.2 lbs when in vacuum mode. This isn’t too high, but it’s higher than the 56 C-E, which is nearly a full pound lighter. Despite the extra weight, you shouldn’t run into too many problems trying to wield it.

Converting the blower into a shredder vac is a straightforward process that can be completed in just a few simple steps. Watch the video further down on this page to see how it’s done.

Whether you’re blowing or shredding, both these units are easy to use. They both have soft-grip handles, letting you easily keep a hold of the tool even at full power. When in blower mode, you can operate either tool one-handed, like any handheld blower.

However, when in shredder vac mode, you’ll need both hands for optimal control and comfort – your right hand on the main handle controlling the throttle and functions, and your left hand on the assist handle for support and guidance.

Both units come with a zippered 1.5 cubic feet collection bag for convenient storing and emptying the accumulated mulch. The bag is designed to be worn over your left shoulder for comfortable and convenient operation.

The vacuum’s built-in shredder doesn’t need any special handling. It automatically kicks in when you start up the vacuum. STIHL’s website mentions a mulching ratio of 14:1 for dry leaves. In other words, the shredder vacs can effectively reduce the volume of dry leaves by 14 times.

Note: there’s no way to shut the shredder funtion off in order to use the tool in vacuum-mode only. If you really need such function these are not the right tools for you.

Build Quality

Both shredder vac models are marked as “Made in America”, but that doesn’t really tell you much about the actual products and the materials used. It’s certainly not a guarantee of quality on its own.

However, you’ll be happy to hear that these units have the same durable casing and can stand up to long-term use. The unit’s built-in metal shredder blade is strong enough to deal with dry leaves and similar-sized debris.

Just keep your tool clean and carry out all relevant maintenance checks as and when necessary, and you should be fine for many years to come.

Price

The SH 86 C-E currently sells for around $370, while the SH 56 C-E goes for $270 (at the time of writing). This is a big difference when you’re not getting much difference in the grand scheme of things, so ask yourself if it’s truly worth it.

Yes, the 86 C-E is a professional blower with more power, but you could save yourself about $100 (at the time of writing). The lower weight and extra fuel capacity could even make it easier to complete the tasks you have in mind. If you’re on a tight budget, go for the 56 C-E.

However, if you anticipate using the tool for longer durations, consider the extra expense as a worthwhile investment, as the SH 86 C-E’s anti-vibration system will prove to be an indispensable feature, providing you with enhanced comfort, reduced fatigue, and improved productivity throughout your landscaping tasks.

Watch the STIHL SH 86 C-E Prove Its Worth

If you’re interested in seeing the STIHL SH 86 C-E perform in real-world situations, be sure to check out this excellent video from K6 Outdoors. In this video Kyle Garringer highlights the key aspects of the SH 86 C-E and demonstrates how to switch between blower and shredder and how the tool performs in each mode, providing valuable insights for both new and experienced users.

VIDEO | STIHL 86 C-E Shredder Vac And Blower – Review And Testing

Final Thoughts

Regardless of which STIHL model you choose, you can rest assured that you’re investing in a top-quality tool. Of course, the shredder vac you go with is up to you and depends on your specific needs and priorities but here’s our verdict.

If you’re on a budget and don’t expect to do particularly heavy-duty work anyway, go for the SH 56 C-E. However, if you look for extra power and place a high value on comfort and the ability to work for extended periods without excessive fatigue, go for the SH 86 C-E.

Related

- Advertisement -

Latest

- Advertisement -